Needs editing and refinement. The part where they just laugh and show hitler quotes to prove he was catholic or just christian moves too quickly to read. The part where they show anti-christian quotes from hitler is glossed over, when it needs to be addressed honestly.
From all I've read it seems clear that we just don't know if he was was atheist or catholic or if he just used whatever to manipulate shit for his own whims.
The clip runs a little long too. Part of the draw is the running joke of how 'obvious' hitler was atheist while actually showing he wasn't. But that joke drags on too long isn't funny or clever by the end. Shortening it will fix that and sharpen the point.
The section where he starts reading all the things rationalist don't believe in gets too messy as well. Especially when he starts overlapping the audio.
I REALLY like the idea of this video and think a lot of it worked well, but it really does need work to make it as great as it could be.
Please redo it Non-Stamp Collector. Maybe make it a shorter 'quiz show' joke section and then add a more serious look at the evidence after it. Then some people could just look at one or the other or both -for diff. audiences.
Very nice!
ReplyDeleteNeeds editing and refinement. The part where they just laugh and show hitler quotes to prove he was catholic or just christian moves too quickly to read. The part where they show anti-christian quotes from hitler is glossed over, when it needs to be addressed honestly.
ReplyDeleteFrom all I've read it seems clear that we just don't know if he was was atheist or catholic or if he just used whatever to manipulate shit for his own whims.
The clip runs a little long too. Part of the draw is the running joke of how 'obvious' hitler was atheist while actually showing he wasn't. But that joke drags on too long isn't funny or clever by the end. Shortening it will fix that and sharpen the point.
The section where he starts reading all the things rationalist don't believe in gets too messy as well. Especially when he starts overlapping the audio.
I REALLY like the idea of this video and think a lot of it worked well, but it really does need work to make it as great as it could be.
Please redo it Non-Stamp Collector. Maybe make it a shorter 'quiz show' joke section and then add a more serious look at the evidence after it. Then some people could just look at one or the other or both -for diff. audiences.
Absoluely brilliant and perfect as it is.
ReplyDeleteOne of my favorite religious debater claims.
ReplyDeleteMein Kampf is an arsenal of religious Hitler quotes.
One of my favorites from a speech of his:
"I believe today that I am acting in the sense of the Almighty Creator. By warding off the Jews I am fighting for the Lord's work."